Between 2007 and 2011, the U.S. Mint released a series of dollar coins commemorating U.S. presidents. But how much are these coins actually worth today? Are any of them worth significantly more than their face value?
Let’s explore the most valuable Presidential Dollar Coins that have come to market. We’ll dive into what makes these coins special and how much they’re worth. If you’re curious about the value of your collection, read on to discover some impressive findings!
1. 2007-D George Washington Dollar, First Day of Issue, MS67 – $475
The 2007-D George Washington Dollar, minted in Denver, is one of the more common coins in the series, with over 163 million produced. However, if you have a coin designated as “First Day of Issue” (FDI), it can be worth significantly more.
Coins that are sent to an independent grading agency on the first day of release are given this special designation, often adding a premium to the price. In this case, the 2007-D George Washington Dollar graded MS67 (mint state) is valued at $475, with only two coins certified at this level.
2. 2007 George Washington Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS68 – $4,250
A rare error in the 2007 George Washington Dollar coins involved missing edge lettering. This error means that the coin’s mint mark, date, and motto were not struck on the edge, making them incredibly rare and sought after by collectors. While many of these coins are worth just a few dollars, the finest examples, such as those graded MS68, are valued at $4,250.
With only three MS68 examples in existence, this coin is one of the rarest Presidential Dollars around.
3. 2007 Thomas Jefferson Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS68 – $6,500
Another example of a Presidential Dollar with a missing edge lettering error is the 2007 Thomas Jefferson Dollar. While many examples were discovered, only a few coins have been graded at the highest level of MS68, with one of these selling for as much as $6,500.
As one of the rarest error coins in the series, this coin’s high value reflects its scarcity and demand among collectors.
4. 2007 James Madison Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS67 – $4,000
The 2007 James Madison Dollar is another coin with a missing edge lettering error. With over 200 million coins struck, only a small subset of these coins exhibit the edge lettering flaw. A coin graded MS67 can fetch up to $4,000, and the market for high-quality error coins remains strong for this mintage.
5. 2008 John Quincy Adams Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS68 – $425
The 2008 John Quincy Adams Dollar is yet another coin with missing edge lettering. However, these errors are not as rare as those from 2007, and thus the value is lower. The finest known example, graded MS68, is worth approximately $425. Despite the larger number of coins with missing edge lettering, this example remains desirable to collectors.
6. 2008-D Andrew Jackson Dollar, Position A, MS67 – $370
The 2008-D Andrew Jackson Dollar features two variants of edge lettering—Position A and Position B. Coins from Position A have upside-down edge lettering when the president’s portrait is facing up. A high-quality coin, graded MS67, is valued at $370. However, these coins are not as rare as others in the series, and prices remain relatively affordable.
7. 2008 Andrew Jackson Dollar, Satin Finish, Missing Edge Lettering, MS69 – $1,000
Coins that have a satin finish and missing edge lettering are prized by collectors, especially those that are in excellent condition. A 2008 Andrew Jackson Dollar with this unique combination and graded MS69 can fetch around $1,000. These special strike coins, produced in limited numbers, are a hit among collectors.
8. 2009-P John Tyler Dollar, Position A, MS68 – $900
The 2009 John Tyler Dollar, minted in Philadelphia, was issued with Position A edge lettering. A coin in mint condition, graded MS68, can be worth $900. Though the production was lower that year, the value of these coins has fluctuated as more high-quality examples have emerged.
9. 2009 William Henry Harrison Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS69 – $1,250
The 2009 William Henry Harrison Dollar was also struck with missing edge lettering, but some coins are much rarer than others. The finest-known example of this coin, graded MS69, has sold for as much as $1,250 in recent years. Its rarity makes it a valuable addition to any collection of Presidential Dollar Coins.
10. 2010 Millard Fillmore Dollar, Missing Edge Lettering, MS69 – $5,500
The 2010 Millard Fillmore Dollar is one of the most valuable Presidential Dollar Coins in the series due to its missing edge lettering error. With a mintage of just over 74 million, this coin is quite rare in the market today. The finest example, graded MS69, is valued at $5,500, making it one of the top-performing coins in terms of value.
Conclusion: Presidential Dollars Worth Money
While most circulated Presidential Dollar Coins are worth only their face value, there are several rare and error coins that have proven to be valuable. These coins, especially those with missing edge lettering or special finishes, are highly sought after by collectors and can fetch impressive prices at auction.
If you happen to own any of these rare coins in mint condition or with special characteristics, you could have a valuable treasure on your hands. Always have your coins appraised by a reputable dealer or grading service to ensure you know their true value!
